BBC faces leadership crisis after news bosses quit over Trump speech edit, bias claims

Former BBC Director-General Tim Davie

London | The BBC was facing a leadership crisis and mounting political pressure on Monday after its top executive and its head of news both quit over the editing of a speech by US President Donald Trump.

The resignation of BBC Director-General Tim Davie and news chief Deborah Turness over accusations of bias was welcomed by Trump, who said the way his speech had been edited was an attempt to “step on the scales of a Presidential Election.” BBC chairman Samir Shah was expected to issue an apology for the actions of the publicly funded national broadcaster on Monday.

The BBC has faced a storm of criticism for misleading editing of a speech Trump made on January 6, 2021, before a crowed of his supporters stormed the Capitol in Washington.

Its “Panorama” documentary programme spliced together two sections of the speech, delivered almost an hour apart, into what appeared to be one quote in which Trump urged supporters to march with him and “fight like hell." Among the parts cut out was a section where Trump said he wanted supporters to demonstrate peacefully.

In a letter to staff, Davie said "there have been some mistakes made and as director-general I have to take ultimate responsibility.” Turness said the controversy about the Trump documentary was “causing damage to the BBC." “In public life leaders need to be fully accountable, and that is why I am stepping down,” she said in a note to staff. “While mistakes have been made, I want to be absolutely clear recent allegations that BBC News is institutionally biased are wrong.” Trump posted a link to a Daily Telegraph story about the speech-editing on his Truth Social network, thanking the newspaper “for exposing these Corrupt 'Journalists.' These are very dishonest people who tried to step on the scales of a Presidential Election.” He called that "a terrible thing for Democracy!" White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt reacted on X, posting a screen grab of an article headlined “Trump goes to war with fake news' BBC” beside another about Davie's resignation, with the words “shot” and “chaser.”

Trump speech edited

Pressure on the broadcaster's top executives has been growing since the right-leaning Daily Telegraph published parts of a dossier compiled by Michael Prescott, who had been hired to advise the BBC on standards and guidelines.

As well as the Trump edit, it criticised the BBC's coverage of transgender issues and raised concerns of anti-Israel bias in the BBC's Arabic service.

The “Panorama” episode showed an edited clip from the January 2021 speech in which Trump claimed the 2020 presidential election had been rigged. Trump is shown saying: “We're going to walk down to the Capitol and I'll be there with you. And we fight. We fight like hell.” According to video and a transcript from Trump's comments that day, he said: “We're going to walk down to the Capitol, and we're going to cheer on our brave senators and congressmen and women, and we're probably not going to be cheering so much for some of them.

“Because you'll never take back our country with weakness. You have to show strength and you have to be strong. We have come to demand that Congress do the right thing and only count the electors who have been lawfully slated, lawfully slated.

“I know that everyone here will soon be marching over to the Capitol building to peacefully and patriotically make your voices heard.” Trump used the “fight like hell” phrase toward the end of his speech, but without referencing the Capitol.

“We fight like hell. And if you don't fight like hell, you're not going to have a country anymore,” Trump said.

A national institution

The 103-year-old BBC faces greater scrutiny than other broadcasters — and criticism from its commercial rivals — because of its status as a national institution funded through an annual license fee of 174.50 pounds (USD 230) paid by all households with a television.

The broadcaster is bound by the terms of its charter to be impartial, and critics are quick to point out when they think it has failed. It's frequently a political football, with conservatives seeing a leftist slant in its news output and some liberals accusing it of having a conservative bias.

It has also been criticised from all angles over its coverage of the Israel-Hamas war in Gaza. In February, the BBC removed a documentary about Gaza from its streaming service after it emerged that the child narrator was the son of an official in the Hamas-led government.

Governments of both left and right have long been accused of meddling with the broadcaster, which is overseen by a board that includes both BBC nominees and government appointees.

Craig Oliver, a former BBC news executive who worked as director of communications for Conservative Prime Minister David Cameron, said those at the top needed to do a better job at defending the corporation.

“We're living in a fast-moving digital world where there are a lot of people who want to attack the BBC," he said.

“It's been obvious for days now that the BBC needed to step up, explain, apologise, move on. And what we've seen is the governance of the BBC saying, 'we'll get back to you on Monday – we'll leave that for days. We'll allow the president of the United States to be attacking the institution, and we're not going to properly defend it.'”